|
|
govil2001 said: beautiful post July 26, '08 |
|
|
dagnysharma said: Relativity, As you said, there is no reason to sparr. I end the debate here. One of your questions I will partially answer. To tell you how she impacted my life... I would need to tell you the precise manner in which it was falling apart. And that would be distasteful for me in the extreme... specially on a public forum... and to a stranger to boot. So, retain your impressions of things and I shall stay with mine. Cheers, Dagny PS: Just for the record, I detest the condescending 'my dear'. I am NOT. Please remember it next time you interact with me. July 20, '08 |
|
|
relativityLEO said: ..contd b) about the book being the largest seller on amazon in 2002. do you have any links to substantiate that? c)out of curiosity, in what way exactly has the book or mme rand's books changed your life? d) about my 'winning friends and influencing people'. there is such a thing called irony. please view my comment in that light. i dont set out intentionally to win friends and/or influence people July 20, '08 |
|
|
relativityLEO said: my dear, i have mentioned this was a personal list of yours and fair play to you, and hence dont see the point of thrust and parry.however since you have engaged in debate.. a) an amazon best seller means nothing. there was recently another best seller on amazon called belle d'jour, essentially the diaries of a call girl. so it got sold like pancakes on amazon. that means it changed the world? capitalism existed before mme ayn rand came onto the scene and is alive and kicking after her departure. her book has not made an iota of difference to the way the american capitalist system works or those in other countries. it does have an appeal to individuals because the utopian freedom she portrays in her book strikes a chord in those who live life surrounded by social,cultural and filial restrictions, which is most people. ...cont July 20, '08 |
|
|
dagnysharma said: ...... contd (2).... Atticus Finch is of course in another class. I didnt include him here because it wasnt him alone. It was his 2 kids too. It was Boo too. The book is too wide a canvas for my limited ability to segragate and hold aloft one character and say HE impacted my life. The story was too moving. Happy you came along.... thanks for the interaction and do please visiting. Cheers, Dagny July 19, '08 |
|
|
dagnysharma said: RelativityLEO and nat_1, I am replying you together since you have the same issue with this list of mine here. :)) I have corrected the typo. And you did 'Win friends and Influence People'. I am not convinced about the first part of that- and am working on that- but the second part I am sure about. My limited reading- and associated tunnel vision- seems to have shocked and revolted you. I wish I could feel sorry. As for Ayn Rands books setting the world alight.. in the first place you are wrong. Atlas Shrugged was the most sold book on Amazon dot com in 2002. It isnt really a reflection on the visionary that people understood her 50 years too late. Secondly, it matters not to me whether the world was set alight. She set my spirit alight. That is all that matters to me. Sam Spade and Lolita are wonderful characters too. As also are many many others. But they didnt impact my life as deeply as these 10 did. ..... contd...(2) July 19, '08 |
|
|
dagnysharma said: Rishu, Just one character?? Come up with 9 more and you got yourself a blog... :)) Cheers, Dagny July 19, '08 |
|
|
nat_1 said: i am more likely to agree with the observations made by relativity leo. there seems to a one dimensional choice of characters in the list of 10. didnt jeeves, dr herriot or heathcliffe never come in your reading? July 18, '08 |
|
|
relativityLEO said: 4 characters from the only the best sellers ayn rand wrote.. is that a reflection of how much you have read? or how much you were able to relate to? do atticus finch, lolita, fagin, holly golightly, philip marlowe, sam spade, madame bovary, brothers karamzov, tarzan..etc ring a bell? and while ayn rand wrote the book in celebration of capitalism and objectivism, the two philosophies she followed, the two books and the characters you mention, didnt really set the world alight. there is one character that could possibly take credit for starting a war. and that's Uncle Tom. you can work out which war that was. and some characters have become part of language, quixotic, oedipus complex, achilles heel, etc and one character has a landmark in london devoted to him. but this is your list, so fair play. but since i am in my 'winning friends and influencing people' mood, i should point out that Howard is Roark and not Rorak. July 17, '08 |
|
|
soundspot said: Jonas Cord – The Carpetbaggers Rich, great-looking, daredevil, entrepreneur stud. One of my favorite books of all time. Neat guy. July 17, '08 |
Recent posts
Recent Visitors